We are a father and son team. Nader (the dad) has been a spiritual director since 2007 (North Park Seminary), and has his Doctor of Ministry in Spiritual Formation from Tyndale Seminary in Toronto. Ben (the son) is the operations pastor at a local Chicagoland church, and a writer who is passionate about prayer and literature. We both have a heart for personal prayer, and long to see others draw near to God in their prayer journeys. We hope the Holy Spirit speaks to you through these entries in the ways that only He knows you need.

Living by Faith: When Our Brains Lie to Us

Forty years ago, psychologist Francine Shapiro was walking in a park in California.   She noticed that she could think about difficult memories with less pain than usual. The next observation she made was that her eyes were moving regularly back and forth. She then began to intentionally think of difficult memories while moving her eyes in the same way, and this caused the memories to become less painful.

Shapiro then took that idea and began trying it out with others, where she would have them remember a difficult memory while watching her move her fingers. The results were encouraging enough that they led to the development of a widely used and highly effective trauma treatment is known as EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing).

I was recently reading an explanation of why this therapy works, and it has a connection to faith that I did not expect.

In his book “The Neuroscience of Psychotherapy,” Dr Lou Cozolino explains that traumatized people develop what is referred to as neophobia[i]. The fear of getting triggered causes them to be less willing to try or experience new things and emotions. For people without trauma, the brain circuits that prepare us for new things and for learning get activated. On the other hand, people with PTSD do not activate those same circuits in response to trauma, instead the regions that organize autobiographical and somatic memory fire instead. They are looking for what was fearful from their past to see if there is reason to be afraid again. This keeps them from new experiences that could provide potential healing. It keeps them from internalizing opposite experiences of safety.

When eyes are moving side to side, it is plausible to see that the brain is open to new information, since that action is what our ancestors needed to forage for food in the wild and to watch out for predators. EMDR then takes advantage of this to bypass PTSD sufferers’ reluctance to receive new information.

This reminds me of Dr. Jeffrey Schwarz’ explanations of how a mis wired brain “lies to us.” [ii]He says we can use our Wise Internal Advocate, by which he means the Holy Spirit inside of us to help us act on truth instead of lies.

Since we know that trauma causes our brains to perceive reality incorrectly, it is a clear case of our brain “lying to us.” This brings me to St. Paul the Apostle’s words in 2 Corinthians 5:7  “For we live by faith, not by sight.” I had always thought that this verse was about seeing things by faith that were not available for us to know by sight. That is true. But bringing these insights together makes me think that there is another huge advantage to living by faith, in that when we live by sight we are vulnerable to being deceived by the miswirings we carry in our brains.

I am reminded of a young woman in my office, paralyzed by social anxiety. Her brain telling her that she would be rejected at every turn. Faith in the truths I told her helped her to take risks and try experiments. Those led to positive experiences, which led to friends, healing, dating, and then marriage.

I have often felt that most types of therapy ideally require faith in the process, faith in the therapist, and faith in God. Living by faith is a healing experience.

 

[i] Cozolino, L. (2017). The neuroscience of psychotherapy: Healing the social brain (3rd ed.). W. W. Norton & Company. 410-411

[ii] Schwartz, J. M., & Gladding, R. (2011). You are not your brain: The 4-step solution for changing bad habits, ending unhealthy thinking, and taking control of your life. Avery.

Suffering With Jesus Changes Our Brains